The Newsletter Barbell: Why the Middle Ground Is Where Profits Go to Die

TL;DR: Successful newsletters operate on a barbell model - either timely curated (like The Hustle's 1.5M subscribers) or timeless leadership (like The Generalist's $1.3M ARR with 90K subscribers). The middle ground kills monetization. Pick your extreme and build everything around that positioning decision.

Here's what most newsletter creators get wrong: they think being "well-rounded" will attract more subscribers. The data says the opposite.

After sending billions of emails and owning 38 newsletters over the past five years, I've discovered something that completely flips conventional wisdom on its head.

The most successful newsletters don't try to be everything to everyone. They pick one extreme and dominate it.

The Death Zone: Why the Middle Kills Monetization

It’s call the newsletter barbell effect, and it's the difference between struggling to make $500 a month and building a seven-figure media business.

Here's the brutal truth: newsletters stuck in the middle ground are profit graveyards.

They're too deep to capture mass attention, but too shallow to command premium pricing. They end up with mediocre engagement, mediocre subscriber growth, and mediocre revenue.

I've watched dozens of creators fall into this trap. They start with a clear vision, then gradually drift toward the middle, thinking they need to appeal to more people. They add lighter content to attract casual readers. They simplify complex topics to reach a broader audience.

The result?

They lose their core positioning and end up with a lukewarm audience that won't pay premium prices for lukewarm content.

The Barbell Winners: Timely vs Timeless

The newsletters making real money operate on what I call the barbell model. They're either extremely curated and timely, or extremely deep and timeless. Nothing in between.

On one end, you have the timely curated approach. These newsletters focus on breaking news, quick summaries, and easily digestible content that people consume daily.

Think rapid-fire business updates, market movements, or trending topics.

The Hustle built this model to perfection, reaching 1.5 million subscribers by delivering bite-sized business news that busy professionals could consume in under three minutes.

On the other end, you have the timeless leadership model. These newsletters charge premium prices for exclusive insights, detailed analysis, and expert-level content.

The Generalist exemplifies this approach perfectly. With just 90,000 subscribers, they generate $1.3 million in annual recurring revenue. That's a 3% conversion rate to paid subscriptions at premium pricing.

Pick Your Lane: The Positioning Decision That Makes or Breaks You

Here's the framework I use to help creators position themselves on the barbell spectrum:

Go Timely Curated if you want to: 

Build massive scale quickly, monetize through advertising and sponsorships, create content that's highly shareable but doesn't require deep expertise. This model thrives on frequency, speed, and accessibility. You become the go-to source for staying informed, not for deep learning.

Go Timeless Leadership if you want to: 

Build a smaller but higher-value audience, monetize through premium subscriptions and high-ticket offerings, leverage your expertise for maximum pricing power. This model thrives on exclusivity, depth, and genuine expertise. You become the premium source for serious practitioners.

The key insight I've learned?

Revenue per subscriber is inversely correlated with subscriber count. The Hustle model might generate $2-5 per subscriber annually through advertising. The Generalist model generates roughly $14.40 per subscriber annually through premium subscriptions.

Your positioning decision determines everything else: your content strategy, your monetization approach, your growth tactics, and ultimately, your revenue ceiling.

Stop Trying to Be Everything

The biggest mistake I see creators make is hedging their bets. They want the scale of shallow/timely content but also want to charge premium prices for deep insights. They want viral growth but also want to maintain authority with experts.

This hybrid approach is exactly why most newsletters plateau at a few thousand subscribers and struggle to generate meaningful revenue.

The barbell effect works because it creates clear value propositions.

Timely Curated newsletters save people time. Timeless Leadership newsletters save people from making expensive mistakes or missing profitable opportunities.

Middle-ground newsletters do neither particularly well.

Pick your lane today. Go extremely timely or extremely timeless. Build your entire content strategy, audience development, and monetization around that choice.

Stop trying to be everything to everyone. The middle ground is where profits go to die, and the data proves it.

Press Send!

~ Nate Kennedy

Launch Your Newsletter In 3 Days

Our Done-For-You Newsletter Setup transforms how creators like you connect with your audience. We don't just set it up; we install a complete newsletter ecosystem that works on autopilot.